Shelter Island Slice

About Shelter Island Slice

Shelter Island Slice, located at 3 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964, is a must-visit pizza place for anyone in the area. The restaurant is known for its welcoming atmosphere and exceptional hospitality, often making visitors feel like they are part of the family. The owner takes great pride in offering personalized experiences, ensuring that every guest leaves satisfied.

One of the standout features of Shelter Island Slice is its homemade cauliflower crust pizza, which is a crowd favorite. Whether you're a health-conscious eater or just someone who loves a unique twist on a classic, this cauliflower crust pizza is a delightful choice. The plain pizza is also a solid option for those who prefer the traditional, always satisfying and delicious.

Another signature dish at the restaurant is the Penne Alla Mimmo. This creamy pasta dish, featuring mushrooms, sausage, ground beef, and a rich pink marsala cream sauce, has earned rave reviews from guests. Many say it’s reminiscent of Don Giovanni’s in Chelsea, making it a must-try for pasta lovers. The dish is often served with fresh garlic bread, adding the perfect touch to your meal.

For those who have a craving for some extra sides, the garlic knots are a popular choice. In fact, they are so beloved that kids can be seen fighting over the last piece. The restaurant also offers generous portions, with giant salads and hearty meals that make it a perfect place for families and groups.

Shelter Island Slice offers convenient hours, staying open until 8:30 pm all year round, making it easy for locals and visitors to enjoy a meal at any time of day. Whether you're dining in or opting for delivery between 4 pm and 8 pm, you can enjoy the best pizza on Long Island in a clean and comfortable setting. The large TV is an added bonus for those looking to catch up on the latest games while enjoying their meal.

If you're in Shelter Island, don't miss out on this hidden gem. The friendly service, high-quality food, and warm atmosphere make Shelter Island Slice an unforgettable dining experience.